Type of Document Dissertation Author Carney, Patrick Koby URN etd-08072005-192228 Title Rankings and Ratings of Literature Selection Criteria among Public School Wind Band Conductors Degree Doctor of Philosophy Department Music, College of Advisory Committee
Advisor Name Title Patrick Dunnigan Committee Chair Clifford Madsen Committee Member James Mathes Committee Member John M. Geringer Committee Member Paul Ebbers Committee Member Keywords
- Wind Conductors
- Wind Band
- Public School
- Selection Criteria
- Literature Selection
- Band Conductors
- Literature Selection Criteria
Date of Defense 2005-08-02 Availability unrestricted AbstractThe purpose of this preliminary study was to investigate the values music educators apply to the selection of wind band literature. Specifically, the purpose was to examine twelve classified objective elements of quality and suitability in the wind band field that influence the selection of literature. Participants (n = 237) were selected from educators teaching middle school, high school, or both in the state of Florida during the 2004-2005 academic year.
Participants (n = 237) were stratified by level of education, level of instruction, and years taught in career categories to determine subjective elements influence the selection of literature. Twelve perceptible elements, six elements of quality and six elements of suitability, were selected for their relevance when used to determine appropriate literature including instrumentation, the experience level of an ensemble, utilitarian purposes, and external influences.
Data were collected in an online survey. The Survey on the Selection of Wind Literature had four sections. The first section was the rating of the twelve objective elements on an individual basis measuring their importance in the selection process using a Likert-type scale. The second section was the ranking of the twelve elements considered as a group to determine their overall relative importance in the selection process. The third section posed several demographic questions. The final section posed three open-ended questions that were optional as disclosed in the email requesting participation in the survey.
In both the rating and ranking sections, three elements, experience level of ensemble, instrumentation of your ensemble, and amount of available rehearsal time, in that order, remained the highest in all analyses of the data. In general, the elements of suitability were rated and ranked consistently higher than the elements of quality. The results of the study suggest that elements of suitability are considered more important than elements of quality when selecting literature.
Recommendations for future research and implications for music education are discussed.
Filename Size Approximate Download Time (Hours:Minutes:Seconds)
28.8 Modem 56K Modem ISDN (64 Kb) ISDN (128 Kb) Higher-speed Access PatrickCarneyDissertation.pdf 3.06 Mb 00:14:11 00:07:17 00:06:23 00:03:11 00:00:16